Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 16 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Place (+/- method) (1)
Place (+/- method) (1)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Participation: Engagement
- Engagement with the instructor and project classroom peers for all portions of Module exercises
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Participation: Preparedness
- Preparedness with materials and supplies to participate.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Participation: Productive
- Productive during workdays, on-time and engaged
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Participation
- Participation during class activities such as in progress reviews, small group discussions, and presentations with instructor and project classroom peers.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 1 Landmark Investigation: Conceptualization
Demonstrate your understanding and conceptualization, including interpretation and experience of the landmark research. This includes preliminary landmark and place sensory sketches.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 1 Landmark Investigation: Exploration & Documentation
Demonstrated exploration and documentation of the landmark research. Identified landmark classification, historical and/or cultural significance.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 1 Landmark Investigation: Craft & Quality of Presentation
Demonstrated your interpretation and experience of the landmark investigation through the use of research and visual aids. Presentation is fully developed meeting the exercise criteria. Rigorous evidence of documentation, visual representation, and effective communication.
threshold: pts
10 to >8.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
8 to >6.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
6 to >4.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
4 to >2.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
2 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
10 pts
--
Ex 2. Intervention: Understanding & Conceptualization
Design a site-specific intervention for your place. Consideration of engagement of materials, fabrication methodologies, and scale will be explored. Understanding and conceptualization of proposed intervention.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex 2 Intervention: Documentation & Exploration
Documentation of explored site-specific location ideas are considered and developed. Consideration of engagement of materials, fabrication methodologies, and scale should be included.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 2 Intervention: Craft & Quality
Consideration of engagement of materials, fabrication methodologies, and scale is explored. Craft and quality of design considerations is evident. Sketches, models, and research is evident.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 2 Intervention: Effective Communication
Effective communication is expressed during peer reviews, instructor meetings, and workshopping sessions. Ideas are clear and demonstrate advancement of ideas.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 3 Representation: Understanding & Conceptualization
Produce a site-map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawings that represent the actual or proposed pathways of interactions and the process of intervening the intervention. Experiential drawings visualize the intervention within Place that convey the recorded or intended interactions of the defined space. Integrate a variety of imagery, text use, and media representation into the site map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawing translations to convey the intervention.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 3 Representation: Documentation & Exploration
Produce a site-map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawings that represent the actual or proposed pathways of interactions and the process of intervening and removal of the intervention. Experiential drawings visualize the intervention within Place that convey the recorded or intended interactions of the defined Place. Integrate a variety of imagery, text use, and media representation into the site map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawing translations to convey the intervention.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 3 Representation: Craft & Quality
Produce a site-map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawings that represent the actual or proposed pathways of interactions and the process of intervening and removal of the intervention. Experiential drawings visualize the intervention within Place that convey the recorded or intended interactions of the defined Place. Integrate a variety of imagery, text use, and media representation into the site map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawing translations to convey the intervention.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Ex. 3 Representation: Effective Communication
Produce a site-map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawings that represent the actual or proposed pathways of interactions and the process of intervening and removal of the intervention. Experiential drawings visualize the intervention within Place that convey the recorded or intended interactions of the defined Place. Integrate a variety of imagery, text use, and media representation into the site map, visual diagrams, and experiential drawing translations to convey the intervention.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Final Review: Display and Slides Summary
Display of visual artifacts for progress reviews, small group discussions, and presentations with instructor and project group peers. Success of and understanding of concepts introduced in the project are made evident by the display of visual artifacts produced and the makers verbal participation and efforts to clarify and describe their experiences through the evolving exercises.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Final Review: Verbal Communication
Verbal Participation for in class activities such as pin-ups, in progress reviews, and small group discussions with instructor and project group peers. Success of and understanding of concepts introduced in the project are made evident by the display of visual artifacts produced and the makers verbal participation and efforts to clarify and describe their experiences through the evolving exercises.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Final Review: Craft and Quality
Success of and understanding of concepts introduced in the project are made evident by the display of visual artifacts produced and the makers verbal participation and efforts to clarify and describe their experiences through the evolving exercises.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Final Review: Clarity and Description of Verbal Presentation
Success of and understanding of concepts introduced in the project are made evident by the display of visual artifacts produced and the makers verbal participation and efforts to clarify and describe their experiences through the evolving exercises.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts
(++)
Excellence, exceeding expectations
4 to >3.0 pts
+
Successfully high effort
3 to >2.0 pts
+/-
Demonstrated good effort
2 to >1.0 pts
-
Needs improvement
1 to >0 pts
--
Minimal to no effort
pts
5 pts
--
Total Points: 100 out of 100